AN OPEN LETTER 
REPLY TO CARSTEN JORGENSEN AND 
THE WORLD HWA RANG DO ASSOCIATION

 TO COME: 
THE FAT MAN: A STORY OF WHORES, DRUGS AND
EMBEZZLEMENT
ECHANIS, AN ENIGMA: A HERO TO SOME,  A SHAME TO OTHERS 
THE NAME SAKES OF A GRAND MASTER
THE STORY OF ERIC LEE:  SHAMEFUL ABANDONMENT 
Recently Posted:WHRDA CONTRACT FOR BLACK BELTS


Last updates: January 13, 2001
 January 18, 2001
   January 23, 2001
January 27, 2001
February 1, 2001

    This open letter and those to follow is the beginning of a public feud better kept private.  To those outside the World Hwa Rang Do Association and the many ex-communicated, there will be little substance of interest here.  It is an internal polemic caused by years of verbal abuse in a public forum.  Since the WHRDA  posted its libelous assault against me on their Web Site: www.hwarangdo.com in the Summer of 1996, I have resisted the temptation to drag personal and internal disputes out into the public. In December of 1996, I posted a response to their personal accusations, and requested that they retract and apologize, but I kept the commentary focused on my memory of events and historical records from other sources on the modern development of Hwa Rang Do.  Four months ago, I discovered that functionaries within WHRDA at Joo Bang Lee's direction were again circulating highly personalized attacks against me to total strangers eighteen years after the supposed events.  I sent a request to Henry Lee and to the organization that the practice be stopped and that they take down the pages in reference to me on their Web Site. I suggested that none of it was necessary to promote their business, and that I was as capable of writing rancid, personalized attacks as were they. 

     I waited until now and they didn't have the common courtesy to reply.  I am ready to respond, and I will continue until they take the offending pages down from their site, post a retraction and apology, however, I care not what they do.  I wish to speak to the neophyte who may be unaware of what lurks behind the facade of high sounding virtues. 

    I would spend more time dealing with the accusations by John Huppuch, but his diatribe is a true reflection of his rather limited IQ and it is not worth spending the energy on this wasted sycophant.  It is enough to say that John Huppuch was a former student of mine from the Aspen Academy of Martial Arts. I awarded him his Yellow Belt and (unfortunately for all concerned) I recommended that he go to Headquarters in Downey to continue studying the art.  For those who know him, his claim posted on his Open Letter , "I have been studying Hwa Rang Do from my master - Hwa Rang Do founder and Supreme Grandmaster Dr. Joo Bang Lee - on a daily basis for over twenty years at the World Headquarters", is the most laughable self congratulatory deceit to come from any of the small clique surrounding the SGMD Joo Bang.  To start with, his rotund physic would belie daily anything other than his corpulent addictions of which there are many, but it is not worth the time to itemize them here.

Carsten Jorgensen     

    Much more entertaining is the Page on the WHRDA site authored by Carsten Jorgensen, a proselyte from Denmark.  At least Carsten is not as intellectually challenged as Huppuch.  I will take on Carsten's Page point by point with regards to his critique of my Personal History written on another page on this site.

  •  Carsten can be forgiven for many misinterpretations of my memory of the early history of Hwa Rang Do since English is not his first language.  More to the point, he can be forgiven because he is not old enough (Twenty-three at the time of writing his critique of me) to have been around when these defining events occurred and therefore takes what he hears from Joo Bang to be truth, the whole truth and nothing but the truth.  The Page on Personal History starts with an explanation of how a number of ex-hwarangdo instructors came together to discuss the possibility of creating a platform for examining the art in a fraternal atmosphere. I mentioned that meeting in San Francisco was called by the First Generation of Instructors: myself, Vicente Montenegro and Gil Kim.  I then mention that the senior instructors at the meeting included Gil Kim, Vicente Montenegro, Mike De Alba, Randy Warner, Jessie Lechuga and myself. There were approximately twenty Black Belts at the meeting.  


  •  Carsten claims that Montenegro does not support the purposes of the group, yet he was there and I speak with him frequently.  I can tell you that Vicente has never ask me to take down any page on this site.  He would be in favor of some form of reconciliation, but he has no official association with WHRDA, never takes his students to be tested before the "Masters" at the Headquarters, pays them no dues nor has any respect for their behavior. 

     
    1993 Meeting of Hwarang Instructors at De Alba's school: Vicente Montengro Center facing, Gil Kim talking to Vicente, Jessie Lechuga to Vicente's right, Randy Warner almost out of photo behind Kim and twenty others.

 

  • Carsten claims that I started three organizations and that each was founded after writing letters to HRD Black Belts and asking them to join some new organization of mine.  In point of fact, the United Federation of Hwarangdo was started by Kil Kim.  I wrote the letter to the attendees of this gathering in Mike De Alba's school in 1993, and it is reproduced and revised on Hwa Rang Do, A Personal History.  I started on the Internet The Society of the Hwarang in 1996, but I have never considered the Society an organization, but rather a place to express an opinion, as a kind of sounding board to evolve the art. This type of discourse, the WHRDA sorely resents. They have an ultimate Authority and he is called Supreme Grand Master Doctor.  Beyond that Pontifical reassurance they are unable to hear any other voice. 

  • It is possible without knowing for certain that Carsten is also referring to a series of letters that I wrote in 1986 when I left the Lee Family organization; I am not sure because he wasn't around at the time.   I explain in another page on this site Warning To WHRDA  Members the detailed reasons why I left and why so many others did the same.  More importantly, I warn the novice who is thinking of joining the World Hwa Rang Do Association that there is a contract they are required to sign before they test for their Black Belt that will convert them into Indentured Servants. I have posted a sample of this contract on a separate page: WHRDA CONTRACT.   I have always made my letters public because the WHRDA is operated like a Mafia where there is only one opinion that matters, and those who question the Don's authority are considered criminal.  It is a special way of thinking and behaving. I will deal with this point below.


  Here is a little photographic evidence which I failed to point out in Personal History. These two photographs were taken by Vicente Montenegro. The one on the Left with Joo Sang Lee executing a Arm Bar/Foot Sweep on me (note my personal logo, The Swallow, on my pant leg) was taken in 1969. The photograph on the Right was taken in 1973 with Joo Sang on the Left with Vicente at his side (after setting the camera on auto expose), I am in the middle and Joo Bang is on the far Right. The two photos were taken in exactly the same location in the room, but in 1969 the only banners that Joo Sang hung on his wall was the American and Korean flags. The patch on Joo Sang's Gi was also the Korean flag, not the now familiar Hwa Rang Do logo.  In 1972, Joo Bang had arrived with a new banner baring the logo of Hwa Rang Do or (Fa Rang Do).  It was only after Joo Bang arrived in the country that the Hapkido sign was taken down and we changed the patches on our Japanese style Karate Gi and the banner on our wall.  

MORE COMING.................


URL: http://www.hwarang.com

Copyright © 1996, Bob Duggan
Designed by Bob Duggan July 1996